Current forum time: 11-18-2026, 10:46 PM


Only together can we build a home for HaShem
Heading into December...
#1
This will be my first time experiencing the November and December "holiday season" on this path, and I'm a little unsure of how things are going to go around Thanksgiving and Xmas and all that.  Does anyone have any experiences or advice they want to share about how you dealt with this when you were new to all of this?  Is it easy to find a middle ground where you aren't necessarily insulting your loved ones, but still keeping a proper distance from certain things?  I feel like this will be a challenge for me.  Is anyone else here also a "first timer" in this regard like I am?  Any thoughts, advice, or even questions are welcome.
Reply
#2
Many Noahides find this time of year difficult, especially when family and friends are celebrating and there are no other Noahides nearby. 
Here are some thoughts.

Chanukah. This holiday has a universal message. In many places the lights are kindled in public, and a speaker shares inspiring words. As a Ben Noah you can attend. At home you can light a menorah too, but do not say the blessing that Jews say, because we are not commanded to light the candles. You can also say Psalm 30, which is connected with Chanukah.

Christmas. For many families it is no longer a religious holiday, but a custom where the family comes together to eat and enjoy each other’s company. The question for a Noahide is: is it only a custom, or is idol worship involved? The Divine Code says the following.
About a tree in the home:
Quote:“In private houses or businesses, it appears that they [the customary trees] are not forbidden for benefit if they bear no symbols of the religion, if they are used only as a custom and not as an aid in worshiping [the idol] with prayers or songs. They would certainly be permitted for benefit after being discarded (a clear act of nullification.)”
(The Divine Code, 4th Edition, Part II, topic 8:10)
About attending and gifts:
Quote:“If one is afraid that others may be angry at him for not participating, or he is afraid of reprisals from the idol worshipers, it is permitted for him to attend and appear as if he is participating, for he is only flattering the idol worshiper, and does not attend out of any acceptance or recognition of the idol...
On a day that they celebrate by giving each other gifts that by their tradition are in honor of their idol, it is permitted to participate in this if it is considered by both parties (the giver and receiver) as only a custom, with no connection to the idol. But it would be better from the outset not to give gifts on that day...”
(The Divine Code, 4th Edition, Part II, topic 10:2)
So if a gift is only a custom for both sides, you may accept it. It is better not to give gifts yourself on that day. Rabbi Moshe Weiner, the author of The Divine Code, also said that for non-Jews it is not sinful if it is only a secular social celebration, with no idol worship and no other forbidden behavior.

For a family celebration at home, there are three cases. If it is only a custom, you may attend. If some family members turn it into a religious service of idol worship, it is forbidden. If only a minority is busy with idol worship and the majority is not, you may attend, but only if refusing would lead to strife. Continuous or frequent acts that serve or praise the idol are forbidden, even if strife may occur. (The Divine Code, 4th Edition, Part II, topic 2:3.)

Saying the name of the holiday is not forbidden if you simply refer to the holiday itself (The Divine Code, 4th Edition, Part II, topics 12:3-4).

In practice. We stopped with Christmas decorations years ago. It felt bare at first, but candles and string lights make a home cozy in the dark days. On New Year’s Eve we stay up if friends visit, but we do not make anything special of it when we are home alone. Sometimes we went on vacation, to avoid discussions with family.
In short: look at each situation by itself, and if you have doubts, ask a rabbi who knows the Noahide laws.


See also : https://sukkatshalom-bneinoach.com/being...dark-days/
Reply
#3
Thank you for the clarification on all that!

This actually makes it a lot easier to plan for, since as far as I know, nobody planning on attending is religious anyway.  Zero chance for any conflict or awkwardness.  It's mostly just a time to get together and enjoy company.

No stress after all!  Good to know!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)